A student asked about this matter — specifically, whether the HSA could have done anything to prevent future applications that amounted to an abuse of the court’s process. My response:
The courts have the following powers in any court proceedings, including but not limited to judicial review proceedings:
- Costs orders: The unsuccessful party generally has to pay a sum of money to the successful party. This sum of money is called “costs”, because in theory it is meant to cover the successful party’s lawyers’ fees. However, the amount of costs is decided (“fixed”) by the court — it is a matter of discretion, and not simply looking at how much the successful party’s lawyers charged. (By the way, that means that even if you succeed in civil litigation, you might end up paying your lawyers more than what you get from the other side in costs!) When proceedings are frivolous or vexatious, or conducted in a frivolous or vexatious manner, that could cause the court to order a greater sum of costs to be paid (see Order 21 rule 2(2) of the Rules of Court). Indeed, even if you succeed, you might be disentitled to costs, entitled to less in costs, or even ordered to pay the losing party’s costs if you have, among other things, acted “unreasonably” (O 21 r 4(b)).
- Power to exert control over the manner in which proceedings are conducted: see sections 73A(2)-(3) of the Supreme Court of Judicature Act 1969 (SCJA). Note that “stayed” can either mean “paused” or “not allowed to continue”; in the latter case, one speaks of a “permanent stay”.
- Extended civil restraint orders and general civil restraint orders, restricting a party’s ability to commence legal proceedings if that party has made applications that are “totally without merit”: see sections 73C-73D of the SCJA. The Attorney-General can also apply for a similar order under s 74 of the SCJA. If such an order is made against you, you cannot commence certain civil proceedings without the court’s permission; and when you ask the court for permission, the court will decide not based on a full trial, but by a summary procedure based on the evidence you present (I’m not sure precisely what the law is, but, in short, this is a relatively short principle in which you have to convince the judge that there is some potential merit in your case).
In your hypothetical situation, the HSA might well ask the court to make such an order — but of course that’s up to the court’s discretion.
Leave a Reply