Benjamin Ong's notes

Notes about Singapore public law, etc. for my students (and possibly others)

Judges in the PCMR

Someone [in a previous class] mentioned the fact that the Chief Justice is a member of the PCMR, and asked: does this compromise his ability to perform his judicial tasks impartially?

This issue was debated when the PCMR was first created. Then, it was called the Presidential Council, and one of its tasks was to scrutinise legislation, not only for whether it contained differentiating measures, but also for whether it violated the fundamental liberties in the Constitution generally.  One might have asked, as did Francis Khoo Kah Siang’s paper at (1969) 1 Singapore Law Review 14 at 16:

“Might it not indeed be futile for private litigants to challenge Acts of Parliament as being discriminatory when the Council has endorsed them? If a Judge of the Court, sitting in the Presidential Council, considers a Bill consistent [with the fundamental liberties provisions in the Constitution], little reason exists to compel him to a different view when that Bill finally becomes an Act and is brought before a Court of law. Furthermore, that Judge will be a Judge in his own cause.”

or, as Thio Su Mien put it in her paper in the same volume, (1969) 1 Singapore Law Review 2 at 6:

“Suppose the Council advises against the enactment of a Bill on the basis that it is unconstitutional but the Government thinks otherwise and goes ahead with its enactment or where the Council makes no report within the prescribed time and the presumption arises that the Council has no adverse comments to make, or suppose the Council advises the Government that a Bill is not inconsistent with the fundamental rights of individuals, hat is the position of these Council-Judges when subsequently faced with litigation challenging the constitutionality of that same piece of legislation? Would they not be judges in their own cause?”

I see the force in this argument, but I respectfully disagree that the judge would be a judge in his/her “own cause”. That phrase is usually used to refer to a situation in which a decision-maker has a stake in the decision one way or another – say, if a judge hearing a dispute between two competing companies owns a huge stake in one of them, or if a judge is personally related to one party.

My preliminary view is this: In the case of the PCMR, all that can be said is that the judge, having once expressed a certain view, will be called upon to change his/her mind. But it is neither unusual nor objectionable for a judge who has once expressed a certain view in one case to depart from that view in another case. One example is Wee Chong Jin CJ’s being part of the court in Chng Suan Tze,which overruled the same Wee CJ’s decision in Lee Mau Seng. More generally, the PCMR, in rendering its report, will not have had the benefit of hearing counsel’s arguments in the case. Besides, in the judgment, the judge will have to explain his/her decision. 

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *