Benjamin Ong's notes

Notes about Singapore public law, etc. for my students (and possibly others)

The history of the PCMR

On the history of the PCMR

The PCMR began as the Presidential Council. Article 81J of the Constitution, which came into force on 9 January 1970, provided: 

“It shall be the particular function of the Council to draw attention to any Bill or to any subsidiary legislation if that Bill or subsidiary legislation is in the opinion of the Council a differentiating measure or otherwise inconsistent with the fundamental liberties of the subject” (emphasis added)

(See the Select Committee report referred to below for the text of the Bill that eventually created the Presidential Council; Parliament passed the Bill, as amended by the Select Committee, on 23 December 1969 without further amendments.)

For more details, see the debates on the Constitution (Amendment) Bill 1969 which took place on 12 June 1969 <https://sprs.parl.gov.sg/search/topic?reportid=003_19690612_S0002_T0002>; the Select Committee report dated 9 December 1969 <https://sprs.parl.gov.sg/selectcommittee/selectcommittee/download?id=188&type=report>; and the further debates on 23 December 1969 <https://sprs.parl.gov.sg/search/topic?reportid=023_19691223_S0002_T0004>. 

For comments on the Presidential Council, see the various articles in volume 1 of the Singapore Law Review.

As for the reason why the Constitution was amended on 2 September 1970 to provide that Bills that “affec[t] the defence or the security of Singapore or which relat[e] to public safety, peace or good order in Singapore” need not be scrutinised by the Presidential Council (and, nowadays, the PCMR: see Art 78(7)(b) of the Constitution), see the debates in Parliament on 2 September 1970 <https://sprs.parl.gov.sg/search/topic?reportid=025_19700902_S0003_T0004>.

It was in 1973 that the Presidential Council became the PCMR, following a recommendation by the Presidential Council itself in its annual report dated 30 April 1971: see <https://www.nas.gov.sg/archivesonline/government_records/Flipviewer/grid_publish/c/c4f96fbc-d3b6-11e7-bbf1-0050568939ad-Cmd.23of1971/web/html5/index.html?launchlogo=tablet/GovernmentRecords_brandingLogo_.png&pn=3> at para 8-9. At paragraph 9, the Presidential Council said:

“… we recommend that this Council’s principal function should be to examine legislation with a view to ‘preventing’ Parliament inadvertently passing laws which discriminate against racial or religious minorities in Singapore”.

So, on 16 February 1973 <https://sprs.parl.gov.sg/search/topic?reportid=019_19730216_S0003_T0004>, the Constitution was amended to rename the Presidential Council to the Presidential Council for Minority Rights, and to change its remit as follows:

“the Presidential Council for Minority Rights will be concerned only with drawing attention to ‘differentiating measures’ in any legislation, principal or subsidiary, that is, measures which are disadvantageous to persons of any racial or religious community. Upon the coming into operation of the Act, therefore, it will not be part of the Council’s functions to draw attention to inconsistencies with the fundamental liberties of the subject as set out in Part II of the Constitution of Malaysia which applies to Singapore.” 

Why is the “defence or security of Singapore” exception there? See https://sprs.parl.gov.sg/search/#/topic?reportid=025_19700902_S0003_T0004.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *