Benjamin Ong's notes

Notes about Singapore public law, etc. for my students (and possibly others)

Being told of your right to counsel: Rajeevan Edakalavan v PP and Miranda v Arizona

In class, referred to Rajeevan Edakalavan v PP [1998] 1 SLR(R) 10 (HC), which held that “nowhere in Art 9(3) does it provide that there is a further right to be informed of one’s right to counsel… there is no obligation imposed on the relevant authority to inform and advise the person under custody of his right to counsel.” (at [19]) One of you asked how this compares to the position in Miranda v Arizona 384 US 436 (1966) https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/384/436/case.html, in which the Supreme Court of the US held, by a 5-4 majority, that there must be “fully effective means are devised to inform accused persons of their right of silence and to assure a continuous opportunity to exercise it”.

I have not had time to read Miranda in full, but skimming it suggests to me that the majority reasoned as follows:

  1. The Fifth Amendment to the US Constitution provides that “No person shall be… compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself…” (emphasis added)
  2. If an accused person is not given a ‘Miranda warning”, etc., then there is a risk that he is pressured into incriminating himself, in violation of his Fifth Amendment privilege. (at 467)

For those of you who would like to learn more about the Miranda case and its applicability to Singapore, I invite you to look at Rajeevan at [16] and how it distinguished Miranda.

Note that Miranda lays down a rule of evidence (only), i.e. breach of the duty to give a ‘Miranda’ warning has the result only that some evidence is excluded.  It does not lead inexorably to the conclusion that the accused must be acquitted.  In Rajeevan, the accused was going further and claiming that the breach of the duty ought to vitiate his plea of guilt.   

Also, note that in Miranda the majority spoke of “inherently compelling pressures which work to undermine the individual’s will”, i.e. its view is premised on the assumption of fact that the failure to give a ‘Miranda warning’ would necessarily amount to a violation of the Fifth Amendment right not to be compelled.  By contrast, in Singapore, it is not as clear to me that the failure to tell someone of his right to a lawyer would amount to a violation of the right to be represented by a lawyer.  Might it amount to compulsion? Perhaps, although, as I understand the law of evidence, that is a question of fact to be determined in each case.

That having been said, even as Rajeevan says that there is no constitutional right to be informed of your constitutional right to be represented by counsel, it suggests that there is a constitutional right not to be misinformed about your right to counsel. At [19]: “The officer under whose custody [the accused] is in cannot be heard to say, ‘you have no right to be defended by a counsel of your choice’. That will be contrary to Art 9(3) and a breach of the arrested person’s constitutional rights.” I say “suggests” because this line can, as I understand it, be read in at least 2 different ways: (a) it is unconstitutional because it has the practical effect of denying you a lawyer, contrary to Art 9(3) which says you have a right to a lawyer; (b) it is unconstitutional because you have a right not to be misled regarding your rights.  Which of the two do you think Yong CJ meant to say?

I also think Miranda may be distinguished as follows.  In Miranda, the majority held that, in order to safeguard your right not to be compelled (right A), you have to be given a certain warning (right B).  But that warning is not just a restatement of right A: the content of that warning is not “You have a right not to be compelled to be a witness against yourself”.  I do not think Miranda goes so far as to say that if you have right A then you have a right to be informed of right A.

Finally, note that some of the dissenting judgments in Miranda argue along similar lines as the court in Rajeevan.

    Comments

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *