Benjamin Ong's notes

Notes about Singapore public law, etc. for my students (and possibly others)

The Eng Foong Ho case and common-law principles of judicial review

Question: Could the Eng Foong Ho case have been argued on the basis of common-law principles of judicial review, in addition to/instead of Article 12 of the Constitution?

Yes, I agree that the applicants could have raised one of the common-law grounds of review in administrative law, and that the ground of irrationality may overlap with how Art 12 works in administrative law. See the High Court’s judgment in Eng Foong Ho [2008] 3 SLR(R) 437 (HC) where the court recorded the applicants’ argument as follows (at [20]): “They contended that if the temple property was accorded different treatment as compared to the mission and the church, the differentiation must be founded on rational reasons. In their view, there were no rational reasons for the differentiation.”

I say that it is an overlap, rather than that the two are identical, for the following reasons. As we have seen, when we talk about irrationality, we need to frame what exactly is the thing we are alleging is irrational. Are we saying that acquiring the temple is irrational? Or that acquiring the temple but not the nearby religious buildings is irrational? By contrast, by using the language of Art 12, it is clear that we are talking about the latter. It becomes clearer that the argument is not that taking the temple is irrational, but rather that taking the temple but not the other two is irrational.  That may, I suspect, by why the applicants framed their application as one under Art 12 rather than one based on irrationality simpliciter.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *