Benjamin Ong's notes

Notes about Singapore public law, etc. for my students (and possibly others)

The “CMIO model”

A student asked about an op-ed by my colleague, Eugene Tan. I responded with the following thoughts:

I would respectfully disagree with Prof Tan if his view is that “sustain[ing]” the “multiple identities of Singaporeans” is, in and of itself, a reason to keep the CMIO model. This is because the state is not the only one who constitutes people’s identities. I will be of my race, and you will be of yours, regardless of whether the state has those facts recorded somewhere. 

But, as I understand it, that is not Prof Tan’s view. I can’t disagree with his pointing out that the promise in Article 152 of protecting minorities can only possibly be fulfilled if there is a way to define who is a minority. 

My issue, rather, is not with classification by the state, but rather with the significance attached to the classification. If I may use a rather personal example: am half Chinese and half Indian. Before I had the race on my NRIC amended to reflect both of these facts, my NRIC simply described me as being “Chinese”. Yet, at this point, I would have taken umbrage at being described as only “Chinese”. This is because, more generally, I would have taken umbrage as being treated as a person constituted only by the state. It may make sense to treat me as “Chinese” for the purposes of some state policies (such as… patrilineality as a facet of patriarchy?), but that does not make me “Chinese” for all intents and purposes.

One could, of course, go further. Is society entitled to treat as single a person who is married in the eyes of a religious authority, but not married in the eyes of the state? What role, exactly, does the state play in saying who we are? I would like to think that every instance on which the state attempts to attach labels to us is something that calls out for justification. In the case of race, I can’t disagree, on the whole, with Prof Tan’s justifications.

Coming back to your point, one may ask: why must the state bother determining what kind of racial/religious minority one is, so long as it has determined that one is a racial/religious minority? There are several possible responses I can think of, but one is that the phrase “interests of the racial and religious minorities” in Article 152 of the Constitution prompts us to consider that different minorities may have different interests which have to be “care[d] for” in different ways. 

Come to think of it, what is a “minority”? That word can mean a group of people which is smaller than the “majority” group: for instance, Malays, Indians, Eurasians, and “others” are minorities because there are fewer of them than there are Chinese. But what if we see “minority” more broadly as a group which is at especial risk of facing certain disadvantages? After all, isn’t the significance of one’s being part of a numerically small group simply that one, qua member of that group, will be be underrepresented in processes which represent groups of people in proportion to how many people there are — such as elections? Isn’t that just a special instance of disadvantage-facing?

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *