On the role of the courts in matters involving Parliamentary privilege, there is one decided case in Singapore: Jeyaretnam Joshua Benjamin v Attorney-General. There, the Committee of Privileges had found Jeyaretnam guilty of abuse of Parliamentary privilege and contempt of Parliament, and fined him. The High Court, referring to Article 63 of the Constitution and the Parliament (Privileges, Immunities & Powers) Act, refused to entertain a challenge to the substance of the decision ([1987] SLR(R) 472 at [12]):
“Our Parliament has the right to control its own proceedings and to regulate its internal affairs without interference by the courts. Whatever matter arises concerning Parliament ought to be examined, discussed or adjudicated in Parliament and not elsewhere.”
The Court of Appeal agreed ([1988] 2 SLR(R) 571 at [13]):
” Parliament at its sitting on 27 January 1987 had resolved that the appellant was guilty of abuse of the privileges and contempt of the Committee and of Parliament and imposed the fines on the appellant. In our opinion, these resolutions of Parliament are conclusive, and it is not open to the court to go behind these resolutions and determine the same issues. Parliament has the right of judging for itself what constitutes abuse of privilege and contempt…”
This would appear, then, to be a limited exception to the general rule that the courts have the final authority to interpret statutes.
That said, neither court denied that the Committee of Privileges was bound to give Jeyaretnam a fair hearing. They were not unwilling to consider Jeyaretnam’s argument that he had not been given a fair opportunity to be heard. However, they found that he had been.
Leave a Reply