Benjamin Ong's notes

Notes about Singapore public law, etc. for my students (and possibly others)

Making the law more accessible

In response to a question from a student, I was reminded of Lord Renton QC’s 1995 Statute Law Society Lecture, titled ‘The Evolution of Modern Statute Law and its Future’ <http://www.statutelawsociety.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/Lord_Renton_lecture.pdf>, where, referencing the Ten Commandments from the Torah, he wrote:

“I am not being entirely frivolous when I remind you that Moses was an excellent draftsman. When he said, ‘Thou shall not steal’, everyone knew what he meant. But we have the Theft Act, 1978, with 36 sections, which have given rise to many problems of interpretation, which have had to be considered many times by the Court of Appeal.”

(The irony is that Renton had mistakenly referred to the Theft Act 1978 when, in fact, he meant to refer to the Theft Act 1968. Both are UK Acts of Parliament which are presently in force.)

If Renton was not being “entire frivolous”, he was not being entirely serious either. It is by no means clear that “everyone knew what [Moses] meant”; even if the word translated as “steal” had a settled meaning, one wonders how far that meaning could be extended beyond the central case of dishonestly taking movable property. Would “Thou shall not steal” criminalise obtaining services from someone else without paying for them (Theft Act 1978, s 3)? What about obtaining Bitcoin or an NFT by fraud? Or personal information? Or electricity (Theft Act 1968, s 13)? Or land (Theft Act 1968, s 4)? Is a distinction to be drawn between taking possession of another’s property and fraudulently inducing a transfer of ownership? Moreover, “Thou shall not steal” fails to distinguish between various varieties of theft which most people would agree should not be treated the same way, from pickpocketing to burglary to armed robbery. Designing rules on the basis that “everyone kn[ows]” what one means is a recipe for disaster.

So, while I see the value in efforts to make the law easier to access (why couldn’t the UK Parliament have combined the Theft Act 1968, the Theft Act 1978, and the Fraud Act 2006 into one?) and to understand (see the AGC’s PLUS project), I am skeptical of calls for the substance of the law to be simplified merely for the sake of being understandable by the average person without assistance. Understandability is not an unqualified good, and is sometimes in tension with other values such as rigour. Moreover, what level of understandability is to be achieved? Surely, if laws (or road signs, or websites with instructions on how to apply for a dog licence, or COVID-19 vaccination instructions) are designed to be understandable by literally everyone, something has to be sacrificed. There comes a point where one ought to consider, not whether the law is understandable without assistance, but rather whether the required assistance is easily accessible.

As for socioeconomic causes of inaccessibility, one matter that particularly irks me is the amount of fees that one has to pay in order to enforce a judgment against someone who will not pay generally — I don’t think charging fees is wrong in and of itself, but charging hundreds can be particularly problematic when the judgment debtor is not particularly wealthy to begin with. For an example, see this blog post from TWC2: https://twc2.org.sg/2018/06/17/when-court-orders-are-worthless-the-zach-engineering-case/. One solution I can think of is to identify certain socioeconomically disadvantaged groups and create a fund to fund the costs of enforcement.

The creation of the ECT as a means to resolve labour disputes only gets one so far, because orders of the ECT are enforceable in the same manner as orders of the District Courts (see the Employment Claims Act 2016, s 22(11)), which are in turn expensive to enforce (see https://www.statecourts.gov.sg/cws/ECT/Pages/Enforcing-a-Tribunal-Order.aspxon enforcement generally, and https://www.statecourts.gov.sg/cws/CivilCase/Pages/EnforcementofJudgmentsorOrdersbyWritofSeizureandSale.aspx on Writs of Seizure and Sale in particular.)

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *