A student asked about the Michael Fay case — specifically, the fact that following a request by the US President, he received fewer strokes of the cane than what he was sentenced to receive. (Specifically, this took place by means of Singapore’s Cabinet advising the President to grant partial clemency.) The student asked about the court’s role. This was my response:
As far as the courts are concerned, they are not entitled to be influenced by foreign pressure or pressure in the form of assurances given by the Government. Both are irrelevant to sentencing.
A case in point is that of David James Roach, whom the UK had extradited to Singapore on condition that he not be caned. Yet, the Singapore courts sentenced him to caning — as they had to, given that robbery carries a mandatory sentence of caning (see section 392 of the Penal Code).
The Singapore government’s promise was instead fulfilled through the President, on the advice of Cabinet, exercising her power under Article 22P(1)(c) of the Constitution to remit part of the sentence.
For more information, see Olivine Lin, ‘Roachgate – No Constitutional Crisis’, Singapore Public Law (27 February 2018), archived at https://web.archive.org/web/20200427070219/https://singaporepubliclaw.com/2018/02/27/roachgate/ (the Singapore Public Law blog is now defunct); and this press release from the MHA: https://www.mha.gov.sg/mediaroom/press-releases/singapore-government-fulfills-assurance-given-to-uk-government-for-extradition-of-david-james-roach/
So the question is: what are the legal limits to Cabinet’s power to advise the President to remit part of a sentence? Specifically, would it be unlawful to exercise this power on the basis of an demand by a foreign state before extradition? I believe a court would say that the answer is no. If the answer were yes, then it would have been unlawful for the Singapore government to fulfil its promise to the UK government, which would mean that the Singapore government would make no such promise, which would mean that Roach would not be extradited to Singapore, which would mean more generally that a person can commit a crime in Singapore and get away with it simply by going to a country which refuses to extradite people to Singapore except if certain promises are made by the Singapore government. That would be a highly undesirable state of affairs.
But, even assuming that I am correct, that doesn’t mean that diplomatic concerns can never be irrelevant to the exercise of the clemency power, such that taking them into account can never be unlawful. A court could, for instance, hold that Cabinet is entitled to advise the President to remit the sentence on the basis of the need to secure the extradition of a person who has evidently committed an offence in Singapore, but not on the basis of a mere desire to please a foreign state. But I am now venturing into speculative territory. I do wonder what the courts would have made of a challenge to Cabinet’s decision to advise the President to partially remit Fay’s sentence of caning.
But then we would run into a practical problem: Who would bring the challenge? Not Fay himself, of course. The only person who would would be the Attorney-General, as guardian of the public interest. But the Attorney-General would ordinarily also have to be represent Cabinet as the respondent, and the President/Cabinet can certainly require him to (Constitution, Art 35(7)). So, in practice, we may never see a case in which the courts have occasion to pronounce on when diplomatic concerns may lawfully be taken into account in a decision to remit a sentence.
One can imagine a complete stranger to the action gaining standing to bring such a challenge by invoking the “grave and serious breaches of legality” limb in Jeyaretnam [2014] 1 SLR 345 at [62]. I wonder who would do so. I might if such a thing happens after retirement and I can afford the time. But in the absence of such a public-spirited individual, it may well be that the limits to the power to remit a sentence will be tested in the political rather than the judicial arena.
Leave a Reply