Benjamin Ong's notes

Notes about Singapore public law, etc. for my students (and possibly others)

Successful applications for judicial review of executive action

(Note: I say “judicial review of executive action” in order to avoid confusion with judicial review of legislation.)

For a (somewhat dated) list of cases in which the applicant succeeded in arguing that some executive action was unlawful, see Chan Sek Keong: ‘Judicial Review — From Angst to Empathy’ (2010) 22 Singapore Academy of Law Journal 469 at Annex A. Some that stand out to me:

Aziz bin Abdul Rahman [1979-1980] SLR(R) 55; Phang Moh Shin [1965-1967] SLR(R) 666: In each of these cases, a police officer’s dismissal was void because he was not given a fair hearing.

Chng Suan Tze [1988] 2 SLR(R) 525: See the video.

Tan Gek Neo Jessie [1991] 1 SLR(R) 1: The Registrar of Businesses ordered someone to change the name of her business, “JC Penney Collections”, on the ground that it was very similar to that of another business called JC Penney Company Inc. The Registrar’s decision was unlawful because she had not taken into account various relevant matters, e.g. that JC Penney Company Inc had not used the name “Penneys” as a trade mark in Singapore.

Fong Thin Choo [1991] 1 SLR(R) 774: A company imported cigarettes into Singapore, claiming that it would export them again soon (i.e. Singpaore was just being used as a transit point) so it did not have to pay duty on the cigarettes. The Director-General of Customs ordered the company to pay duty because he concluded that the company had failed to export the cigarettes. The court held that the Director-General had acted unlawfully because his inspectors’ “investigation was neither fair nor sufficient”: the inspector “failed to investigate fully the evidence produced by the [company and its directors]” and “did not give a fair hearing to the applicants”, instead “hear[ing] one side of the story without hearing the other side” (at [54]).

Pang Chen Suan [2008] 3 SLR(R) 648: The Commissioner for Labour had acted unlawfully in dismissing a worker’s claim for compensation under what was then known as the Workmen’s Compensation Act (now, see the Work Injury Compensation Act). The Act said that the worker had to make his claim within a certain time limit, but could make his claim past that limit if he had “reasonable cause”. The Commissioner for Labour had proceeded on a misunderstanding of what the phrase “reasonable cause” meant.

Stansfield Business International Pte Ltd [1999] 2 SLR(R) 866: The Minister for Labour, in deciding that a worker had been “dismissed without just cause or excuse”, had failed to give a fair hearing to the employer.

Tan Seet Eng [2016] 1 SLR 779: You’re probably tired of hearing about this case by now.

Note also that, even though the majority of applications for judicial review of executive action don’t succeed, that could well be because (a) executive bodies tend not to act unlawfully; (b) other mechanisms, such as informal negotiations or statutory appeals, are a sufficient safeguard against unlawfulness; and/or (c) applicants sometimes don’t run the best legal arguments possible.

In addition, note that there can be cases where the applicant does not succeed, yet the court makes important statements that keep the respondent on its toes. For example, in Gobi a/l Avedian [2020] SGCA 77, the applicants’ argument that their imminent execution would be unlawful failed, but the Court of Appeal did point out that it was unlawful for the Singapore Prison Service to send copies of prisoners’ documents to the AGC. This is not limited to judicial review proceedings. For example, Parti Liyani’s application for compensation ([2021] SGHC 146) failed, but the court did state: “If cross-examination at trial reveals severe weaknesses in the testimony of the witnesses or new evidence is discovered that destroys the very crux of the Prosecution’s case, the onus is on the Prosecution to re-evaluate its case and decide if the prosecution should continue. If it is appropriate, the Prosecution should, as ministers of justice, exercise its discretion to discontinue the proceedings.”

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *