Benjamin Ong's notes

Notes about Singapore public law, etc. for my students (and possibly others)

On a question about “detention without trial”

  1. “Detention without trial” is not a term of art. It refers simply to detention other than imprisonment following criminal proceedings involving a trial (although, in practice, I have not heard of anyone using the term to refer to imprisonment following criminal proceedings in which the accused person has pleaded guilty — there is no trial, but the accused person could have claimed trial).
  2. That said, implicit in the term “detention without trial” is an assertion that detention following a trial (or an opportunity to stand trial) is the norm, and other types of detention the exception; and that the exception merits especial comment. In this sense, “detention without trial” is something of a loaded term, not unlike “termination without notice”.
  3. Why is a trial in open court (or an opportunity to claim trial) considered the norm? Consider what a trial entails. It entails the testing of evidence against/in favour of someone, but that is not all: a trial (as traditionally conceived of) involves publicity. Read about the principle of “open justice” for more on why importance is often ascribed to such publicity.
  4. Various legal systems have struggled with the problem of how to balance the impulse to stick to the norm of a trial with reasons for a trial not to be held. It is not true that the system Singapore has under the CLTPA/ISA is the only possible one. Consider, for example, “closed material procedures” in the UK. These are court proceedings involving the hearing of evidence that, in the state’s view, should not be disclosed to the public. Such proceedings are held behind closed doors: typically, only the judge and lawyers who have been security-cleared are in attendance. This means that even the accused person (or person on whom the state proposes to impose restrictions) himself/herself will not have access to that evidence; only his/her lawyer (known as a “special advocate”) will. Of course, this system is not beyond criticism.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *