In class, I mentioned a case involving someone who cut a woman’s hair without her consent. That case is Director of Public Prosecutions v Smith (Michael Ross)[2006] EWHC 94. Sir Igor Judge P (P stands for “President of the Queen’s Bench Division”; “Judge” here is not a title, but a surname) held that that counts as “assault occasioning actual bodily harm”, which is an offence in English criminal law. The reasoning was simple: hair is a part of the human body. (Judge P added that “an individual’s hair is relevant to his or her autonomy. Some regard it as their crowning glory.”, but that was just obiter.)
I take issue with the following statement by Cresswell J: “… to a woman her hair is a vitally important part of her body. Where a significant portion of a woman’s hair is cut off without her consent, this is a serious matter amounting to actual… bodily harm”.
What is the ratio of this case? Is it that cutting anyone’s hair counts as “assault occasioning actual bodily harm”? Or is it only that cutting a woman’s hair counts as such? I would like to think that it is the former, and I believe that is the generally accepted view in English law. But one can see why Cresswell J’s remark may have caused confusion. So this is a case study in being careful when writing.
(By the way, Cresswell J was wrong to state that Judge P had “said” that “to a woman her hair is a vitally important part of her body”. Judge P had said that about any individual — he used phrases including “the hair is an attribute and part of the human body”; “an individual’s hair”; “his or her” — and not just a woman.)
Leave a Reply