If a reasonable reader would think that a complete answer to the question must address A, B, and C, and if you only address A and B, then you should explain why you are not addressing C. Otherwise, one might get the impression that the paper does not completely answer the question because it doesn’t address C.
This is, by the way, similar to other general skills such as explaining one’s methodology and stating one’s assumptions.
What could be a valid reason for omitting C? Possibilities include the following (all of which, of course, would need to be substantiated):
- At first glance C is relevant to the question, but actually it is not.
- C is actually a subset of A and/or B.
- The paper illustrates a broad principle. It is trite that that principle applies to C. What is less clear is whether the principle also applies to A and B. Therefore, the bulk of the discussion will focus on A and B.
- C is theoretically relevant, but it hardly arises in practice.
Note that all of these require an explanation of why it is justifiable not to discuss C. It is not enough to say that you are not discussing C because of time/space constraints. This is because one might retort: if you want to save time and space, why not omit A or B instead of omitting C? Even if your aim is to save space, something needs to say about why C is the thing that is omitted in order to achieve this aim.
Leave a Reply