Suppose Candidate A gets 1 vote, Candidate B gets 1 vote, Candidate C gets 2 votes, and every other vote is spoiled. Candidate C is duly elected President. Who will lose their deposit?
Section 10(1) of the Presidential Elections Act 1991 says that a candidate must put up the required deposit “between the date of the issue of the writ under section 6 and 12 noon of nomination day”.
Section 10(5) of the Presidential Elections Act 1991 says: “If a candidate who has made the required deposit is not elected and the number of votes polled by the candidate does not exceed one-eighth of the total number of votes polled, the amount deposited is forfeited and must be paid into the Consolidated Fund.” (Section 10(6) says that otherwise, the deposit is to be refunded to the candidate.)
In my view, Candidates A and B will not forfeit their deposits because they each received more than “one-eighth of the total number of votes polled”. In my view, a spoiled ballot paper does not count as one of the “votes polled”. This is because sections 32(6) and 33 describe such a ballot paper as “invalid” and “rejected”. I do acknowledge, however, that my view is open to debate: the Act is not entirely clear on the meaning of “votes polled”. (It is, however, very clear that Candidate C wins. According to s 32(8D), the winner is determined according to the “number of votes given to the candidates”. It is clear that a spoiled vote is not a vote “given to” any candidate.)
Candidate C will not forfeit his deposit. In my view, he received more than “one-eighth of the total number of votes polled”. But even if I am wrong in this view, it is clear that he will not lose his deposit because he was “elected”.
Now, suppose there are ten candidates. 11% of voters vote for Candidate X. 9.88% of voters vote for each of the other candidates. 0.08% of voters spoil their votes. Here, although Candidate X has not received more than “one-eighth of the total number of votes polled”, he will still not forfeit his deposit, because he was “elected”. All the other candidates will lose their deposits, because each of them has not received more than “one-eighth of the total number of votes polled”.
Leave a Reply