Benjamin Ong's notes

Notes about Singapore public law, etc. for my students (and possibly others)

On a question about the “right to vote”

Rights can be positive or negative. The phrase “right to vote” could mean: (a) a right not to be stopped from voting; (b) a right to be provided with a means to vote.

The right to vote is not the only right. In the US, many cases involving voting are argued on the basis of the right to equality before the law, not a right to vote per se.

Non-constitutional rights are still rights. The phrase “right to vote” could well refer simply, for example, to the rights set out in the Parliamentary/Presidential Elections Act.

One could also argue that the right to vote includes ancillary rights like an implied right to receive information about candidates, etc. (If you’re interested, consider Australian case law on the implied freedom of political communication?)

What is the content of the implied right to vote? Consider, first, the test for when something can be said to be implied in the Constitution (or an ordinary statute, or indeed any document). Then consider what precisely is to be implied. The precise content of the right can make a difference. 

For example, if the constitutional right to vote is merely a right that there be some way to vote, then it would follow that it would not be unconstitutional, say, for Singapore to have just one polling station that is not easily accessible by public transport, etc. Or consider the situation if the constitutional right extended only to people without a criminal record, people with work experience, etc. (Of course, there could easily be an express right with such limited content, but at least it would be clear that that is all there is to the right.)

If you agree that the “implied right to vote can be easily negated”, consider why it can be. Is it that all implied rights “can be easily negated”? Or is there something specific about voting? etc. 

One could ask: why not amend the Constitution to make the right to vote express? One possible reason I can think of is: to avoid giving the impression that something is being added that didn’t exist before. Consider also the difficulties with coming up with a comprehensive statement, not only of the right, but also of the limits to the right.

On whether deepfakes undermine the right to vote

A useful starting point might be: what’s so special about deepfakes, that is different from other forms of false/misleading statements? One might ask: there are already regulations relating to false statements; why should deepfakes be treated as being in a separate category? And even if we agree that deepfakes are harmful, why should we conceive of that harm as being a threat to the right to vote?

(By the way, this kind of thinking — about how to characterise a problem — is useful to bear in mind when tackling all sorts of legal questions, if not all sorts of questions generally.)

Note also that the question focuses on whether deepfakes need to be regulated; it does not ask only about whether, if the answer is yes, existing law is enough to do so. You could, of course, discuss what you say is the best means (if any is needed) to regulate deepfakes, but don’t forget other issues – for example, whether deepfakes threaten to “undermin[e]” the “right to vote”, or, indeed, whether the threat posed by deepfakes is best understood as a threat against the right to vote.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *